The Unintended Consequences of More Sunshine

The Unintended Consequences of More Sunshine

VVP President's Posts


There are few things Coloradans love more than sunshine.


So, it's hard to oppose something called the Sunshine Protection Act. The name alone sounds like common sense. Who wouldn't want more sunshine?


But good public policy isn't just about good intentions. It's about understanding the tradeoffs that come with every decision. Before we rush to solve one problem, we need to think carefully about the new problems we might create.


That's why we should take a closer look at the growing push to make daylight saving time permanent.


Like many people, I'd be perfectly happy to stop changing the clocks twice a year. Many wonder why we're still doing it. The inconvenience is real, and the disruption to sleep and schedules serves little purpose in modern life.


Supporters of permanent daylight-saving time focus on the benefits of longer evenings. More daylight after work means more time to walk, bike, golf, shop, dine outdoors or simply enjoy Colorado's quality of life. Those are legitimate benefits.


The question is what happens to our mornings.


When you move daylight from the morning to the evening during the winter, you inevitably create darker starts to the day. In a state like Colorado, where many people are on the road before sunrise and winter conditions can be challenging, that is more than a minor inconvenience.


Think about life here.


Long before the first chair begins spinning, thousands of people are already at work. Snowmakers, groomers, mechanics, lift operators, ski patrol teams and transportation workers are preparing our mountains for another day. Their jobs don't begin when guests arrive. Their work starts hours earlier.


Permanent daylight-saving time wouldn't change that reality. It would simply push sunrise later on the clock. The result is that more employees would be working in darkness during the winter months and resort operating hours would need to shift.


Our schools face a similar challenge.


A child waiting for a school bus on a snowy morning doesn't care what Congress calls the policy. What matters is whether drivers can see them and whether they can safely see traffic approaching.


Anyone who has navigated an Eagle County winter understands that darkness, snow, and ice already demand extra caution. Adding more dark mornings should give us pause.


This is where national conversations sometimes miss local realities.


What sounds appealing in Washington, D.C. can have very different consequences in mountain communities. Colorado's economy, geography and daily rhythms are unique. Winter recreation isn't simply a lifestyle amenity; it's a major economic engine. Transportation challenges are not occasional disruptions. They are part of everyday life during the winter months.


That's why one-size-fits-all solutions deserve scrutiny.


If the goal is to eliminate the twice-yearly clock change, there is another option: permanent standard time.


That approach would achieve the same objective while preserving more natural morning light, something many sleep researchers and health experts prefer. More importantly for communities like ours, it would better align daylight with the times when people are heading to work, taking children to school, and preparing ski mountains for another day.


The broader lesson extends beyond daylight saving time.


A proposal can have a great name, broad popularity, and good intentions while still creating consequences that deserve closer examination. But before we decide that more evening sunshine is automatically better, let's consider what we're giving up in return. For mountain communities, darker winter mornings could mean greater safety concerns, resort operational challenges, and unintended costs that far outweigh the convenience of a later sunset.


The best public policy isn't measured by how good it sounds. It's measured by how well it works in the real world, including understanding the unintended consequences.


Chris Romer is president & CEO of Vail Valley Partnership, 3-time national chamber of the year. Learn more at VailValleyPartnership.com 

 

Additional Info

Organization Name : Vail Valley Partnership

Powered By GrowthZone