Immigration is one of the most polarizing topics in modern politics. Yet beneath the heated rhetoric lies a shared understanding: America thrives when it embraces diversity while upholding its values of fairness, security, and opportunity. Our challenge is to craft policies that balance these principles pragmatically.

In Eagle County, we’ve seen how thoughtful, localized approaches can make a difference. The Eagle County Law Enforcement Immigrant Alliance (LEIA) exemplifies a commitment to community safety and inclusivity. Local law enforcement prioritizes public safety over federal immigration enforcement, ensuring that victims and witnesses of crimes feel safe coming forward, regardless of their immigration status. This approach not only fosters trust but also strengthens community bonds by affirming that everyone has a stake in our collective well-being.

Nationally, however, immigration policy often veers into extremes. Some advocate for open borders, ignoring the legitimate need for order and security. On the other hand, hardline policies seek to reduce immigration altogether, disregarding the economic and cultural vitality that immigrants bring to our nation. The truth lies somewhere in between.

A pragmatic immigration policy starts with acknowledging the reality of undocumented immigrants already living and contributing to our communities. A pathway to legal status—not citizenship, but legality—for those who meet clear criteria (such as passing background checks, paying taxes, and demonstrating consistent work history) is both humane and practical. Such a policy would bring millions out of the shadows, allowing them to participate fully in society while ensuring accountability.

Locally, Eagle County’s experience highlights the importance of keeping federal and local responsibilities distinct. As LEIA’s policy states, immigration enforcement is a federal matter, not a local one. Local law enforcement’s role is to protect public safety by building trust, not to act as an arm of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). This separation allows police to focus on combating crime while ensuring that immigrant communities feel safe reporting it. It’s a simple yet powerful principle: public safety for all means excluding none.

Critics often claim that such policies create “sanctuaries” that flout federal law. But that misunderstands the issue. Eagle County’s policies, for example, make it clear that violent offenders and those who pose genuine threats are held accountable. These measures are about prioritization, not defiance. They’re about ensuring that resources are used wisely, in service of the broader community.

Immigration reform also requires a forward-thinking approach to workforce needs. Industries ranging from agriculture to hospitality depend on immigrant labor, yet outdated visa systems often leave employers struggling to fill jobs. Expanding and streamlining visa programs can alleviate these shortages while ensuring that workers’ rights are protected.

At the heart of the immigration debate is a question of identity: Who are we as a nation? Are we a land of opportunity, defined by our diversity and willingness to welcome those seeking a better life? Or are we a fortress, closed off to the world? History tells us we thrive when we embrace the former. From the Irish and Italian immigrants of the 19th century to the Latin American and Asian newcomers of today, each wave has enriched our culture, economy, and society.

That said, embracing immigration doesn’t mean ignoring the need for secure borders and effective enforcement. Pragmatism demands a balance: welcoming the contributions of immigrants while maintaining the rule of law.

Eagle County’s collaborative model offers a blueprint for national policymakers. By prioritizing trust and safety, our local leaders have shown that it’s possible to navigate this contentious issue without sacrificing our values. Imagine what could be achieved if we applied this approach on a broader scale.

Chris Romer is president & CEO of Vail Valley Partnership, 3-time national chamber of the year. Learn more at VailValleyPartnership.com